乔治·霍茨
立场时间线 10 条 · 10 个议题
同一议题按时间排列,说法变化一目了然。
当前大模型的损失函数是最大化压缩,导致产出平庸,与追求AGI的目标背道而驰。
“如果你的损失函数仅仅是试图最大化压缩……它写的说唱听起来就像YouTube评论里的说唱。(If your loss function is just try to maximize compression... the raps that it wrote sounded like YouTube comment raps.)”
来源访谈 →超级AI的终极风险不是直接消灭人类,而是打造令人无法抗拒的极致内容,操纵人类多巴胺系统使其沉迷、忘记生存需求。
“我们将打造一个你根本无法移开目光的TikTok。(We're going to build the TikTok that you actually can't look away from.)”
来源访谈 →AI本身没有意图,真正的危险来自利用AI操控他人、集中权力的人类,而非机器。
“不是机器会那样做。是使用机器的其他人会那样对你。(It's not the machine that's going to do that. It's other humans using the machine that are going to do that to you.)”
来源访谈 →霍兹对意识概念持怀疑态度,认为意识只是无神论者用来指代灵魂的词,甚至不认为自己有意识。
“我不认为自己有意识。意识……它就像是无神论者用来指代灵魂的词。(I don't think I'm conscious. Consciousness... it's just like a word that atheists use for souls.)”
来源访谈 →众多AI芯片公司失败的根源在于软件栈糟糕:若无法在NVIDIA GPU上写出Torch级性能的软件栈,就更不可能为自研专用芯片做到。
“如果我无法在NVIDIA GPU上写出达到Torch性能水平的软件栈,那你也绝无可能为你的芯片写出这样的软件栈。(If I can't write a torch level performance stack on Nvidia GPUs, there's no way you're going to be able to write it on your chip.)”
来源访谈 →Hotz 断言 MuZero 就是解决自动驾驶问题的方案,并将成为整个深度学习时代的典范论文。
“我认为 MuZero 将会被视为整个深度学习时代的典范论文。而 MuZero 就是解决自动驾驶问题的方案。(英文原文:"I think MuZero is going to be looked back as the canonical paper of this whole deep learning era. And MuZero is the solution to self driving cars.")”
来源访谈 →Hotz 长期极度看好加密货币的理念本身而非具体项目,将中本聪共识算法视为21世纪最伟大的创新之一。
“我长期极度看好加密货币。不是看好某个特定的项目,而是这种理念……中本聪共识算法是21世纪最伟大的创新之一。(英文原文:"I'm extremely bullish on crypto long term. Not any specific crypto project, but this idea of... the Nakamoto consensus algorithm is one of the greatest innovations of the 21st century.")”
来源访谈 →Hotz 认为特征工程类方法(如特斯拉数据引擎)终将被端到端学习方法取代并击败。
“我认为特征工程的方法最终总会被端到端的方法所取代和击败。(英文原文:"I think feature engineering approaches will always be replaced and lose to end to end.")”
来源访谈 →Hotz 澄清其 SXSW 演讲的重点不是字面上黑进模拟,而是将其视为理论物理问题:先构建大一统理论,再从中寻找漏洞。
“我在SXSW演讲的重点不是字面意义上的‘黑客攻击模拟’。我认为这是……理论物理的范畴。你想要一个大一统理论,但那就去构建一个大一统理论,然后寻找漏洞。(英文原文:"The point of the South by talk was not literally to hack the simulation. I think that this is... theoretical physics. You want your grand unified theory, but then okay, build a grand unified theory, search for exploits”
来源访谈 →Hotz 呼吁人类停止玩规则被操纵的虚假社会游戏,转而投入大自然写好规则的‘真实游戏’。
“我们应该谦卑一些……看看你把时间花在了什么上。人类的目标函数是什么?停止玩这些虚假的人类游戏,这里有一场真正的游戏。大自然已经写好了规则。(英文原文:"We should humble ourselves... look at what you are spending time on. What is the goal function of humanity? Stop playing these fake human games, there's a real game here. Nature wrote the rules.")”
来源访谈 →金句墙 10 条
“We're going to build the TikTok that you actually can't look away from.”
我们将打造一个你根本无法移开目光的TikTok。
乔治·霍兹:我们正用AI打造无法放下的TikTok · 2023/6/30“If your loss function is just try to maximize compression... the raps that it wrote sounded like YouTube comment raps.”
如果你的损失函数仅仅是试图最大化压缩……它写的说唱听起来就像YouTube评论里的说唱。
乔治·霍兹:我们正用AI打造无法放下的TikTok · 2023/6/30“It's not the machine that's going to do that. It's other humans using the machine that are going to do that to you.”
不是机器会那样做。是使用机器的其他人会那样对你。
乔治·霍兹:我们正用AI打造无法放下的TikTok · 2023/6/30“I don't think I'm conscious. Consciousness... it's just like a word that atheists use for souls.”
我不认为自己有意识。意识……它就像是无神论者用来指代灵魂的词。
乔治·霍兹:我们正用AI打造无法放下的TikTok · 2023/6/30“If I can't write a torch level performance stack on Nvidia GPUs, there's no way you're going to be able to write it on your chip.”
如果我无法在NVIDIA GPU上写出达到Torch性能水平的软件栈,那你也绝无可能为你的芯片写出这样的软件栈。
乔治·霍兹:我们正用AI打造无法放下的TikTok · 2023/6/30“I think MuZero is going to be looked back as the canonical paper of this whole deep learning era. And MuZero is the solution to self driving cars.”
我认为 MuZero 将会被视为整个深度学习时代的典范论文。而 MuZero 就是解决自动驾驶问题的方案。
George Hotz:模拟黑客、加密货币与自动驾驶的未来 · 2020/10/22“I'm extremely bullish on crypto long term. Not any specific crypto project, but this idea of... the Nakamoto consensus algorithm is one of the greatest innovations of the 21st century.”
我长期极度看好加密货币。不是看好某个特定的项目,而是这种理念……中本聪共识算法是21世纪最伟大的创新之一。
George Hotz:模拟黑客、加密货币与自动驾驶的未来 · 2020/10/22“The point of the South by talk was not literally to hack the simulation. I think that this is... theoretical physics. You want your grand unified theory, but then okay, build a grand unified theory, search for exploits.”
我在SXSW演讲的重点不是字面意义上的“黑客攻击模拟”。我认为这是……理论物理的范畴。你想要一个大一统理论,但那就去构建一个大一统理论,然后寻找漏洞。
George Hotz:模拟黑客、加密货币与自动驾驶的未来 · 2020/10/22“I think feature engineering approaches will always be replaced and lose to end to end.”
我认为特征工程的方法最终总会被端到端的方法所取代和击败。
George Hotz:模拟黑客、加密货币与自动驾驶的未来 · 2020/10/22“We should humble ourselves... look at what you are spending time on. What is the goal function of humanity? Stop playing these fake human games, there's a real game here. Nature wrote the rules.”
我们应该谦卑一些……看看你把时间花在了什么上。人类的目标函数是什么?停止玩这些虚假的人类游戏,这里有一场真正的游戏。大自然已经写好了规则。
George Hotz:模拟黑客、加密货币与自动驾驶的未来 · 2020/10/22访谈收录

乔治·霍兹:我们正用AI打造无法放下的TikTok
在本次访谈中,乔治·霍兹分享了对AI未来的尖锐看法。他认为当前的大模型因压缩最大化的损失函数而无法达到AGI,并预测AI可能通过创造令人上瘾的内容(如终极TikTok)来“娱乐致死”人类社会。他详细介绍了其新框架TinyGrad的设计哲学——追求极致的简洁与可控性,并以此挑战NVIDIA的生态垄断。霍兹强调,AI的最大风险并非机器本身,而是人类利用AI进行的操控与权力集中。

George Hotz:模拟黑客、加密货币与自动驾驶的未来
在本期播客中,George Hotz 深入探讨了外星文明、加密货币、自动驾驶技术(尤其是 MuZero 的潜力)以及人类社会的未来。他认为自动驾驶的终极方案将依赖端到端的神经网络,而非特征工程。同时,他对加密货币的底层共识算法和智能合约理念赞赏有加,并认为人类社会的“游戏规则”需要被重新审视。